Extensive research has shown that no matter how knowledgeable a clinician might be, if he or she is not able to open good communication with the patient, he or she may be of no help.”
Research evidence indicates that there are strong positive relationships between a healthcare team member’s communication skills and a patient’s capacity to follow through with medical recommendations, self-manage a chronic medical condition, and adopt preventive health behaviors. Studies conducted during the past three decades show that the clinician’s ability to explain, listen and empathize can have a profound effect on biological and functional health outcomes as well as patient satisfaction and experience of care.
Patients’ perceptions of the quality of the healthcare they received are highly dependent on the quality of their interactions with their healthcare clinician and team There is a wealth of research data that supports the benefits of effective communication and health outcomes for patients and healthcare teams. The connection that a patient feels with his or her clinician can ultimately improve their health mediated through participation in their care, adherence to treatment, and patient self-management. Yet, it is estimated that one-third of adults with chronic illnesses underused their prescription medication due to cost concerns; yet they fail to communicate this information to their physician Another study found that less than half of hospitalized patients could identify their diagnoses or the names of their medication(s) at discharge, an indication of ineffective communication with their physicians.
The Institute of Medicine (IOM) Report on Health Professions and Training has identified that doctors and other health professionals lack adequate training in providing high quality healthcare to patients. The IOM called upon educators and licensing organizations to strengthen health professional training requirements in the delivery of patient-centered care. The patient-centered care model underscores the essential features of healthcare communication which relies heavily on core communication skills, such as open-ended inquiry, reflective listening and empathy, as a way to respond to the unique needs, values and preference of individual patients
Healthcare Communication Outcomes
A clinician may conduct as many as 150,000 patient interviews during a typical career. If viewed as a healthcare procedure, the patient interview is the most commonly used procedure that the clinician will employ. Yet communication training for clinicians and other healthcare professionals historically has received far less attention throughout the training process than have other clinical tasks.
This is so even as evidence continues to mount that a structured approach to communication measurably improves healthcare delivery.
- Most diagnostic decisions come from the history-takingcomponent of the interview . Yet, studies of clinician-patient visits reveal that patients are often not provided the opportunity or time to tell their story / history, often due to interruptions, which compromise diagnostic accuracy. Incomplete stories /history leads to incomplete data upon which clinical decisions are made.
- When interruptions occur, the patient may perceive that what they are saying is not important and leads to patients being reticent to offer additional information.
- The bottom line is that when patients are interrupted, it is a deterrent to collecting essential information and it hinders the relationship.
Adherence is defined as the extent to which a patient’s behavior corresponds with agreed upon recommendations from a healthcare provider Certainly, we are all aware of the huge problem of non-adherence in health care. For instance, a Health Care Quality Survey conducted by the Commonwealth fund found that 25% of Americans report they did not follow their clinician’s advice and provides the reasons cited in this survey:
1. 39% disagreed with what the clinician wanted to do (in terms of recommended treatment)
2. 27% were concerned about cost
3. 25% found the instructions too difficult to follow
4. 20% felt it was against their personal beliefs
5. And 7% reported they did not understand what they were suppose to do
The core elements comprising patient satisfaction include:
- Expectations: Providing an opportunity for the patient to tell their story.
- Communication:patient satisfaction increased when members of the healthcare team took the problem seriously, explained information clearly, and tried to understand the patient’s experience, and provided viable options.
- Control:Patient satisfaction is improved when patients are encouraged to express their ideas, concerns and expectations.
- Decision-making:Patient satisfaction increased when the importance of their social and mental functioning as much as their physical functioning was acknowledged.
- Time spent:Patient satisfaction rates improved as the length of the healthcare visit increases.
- Clinical team:Although it is clear that the patient first concern is their clinician, they also value the team for which the clinician works.
- Referrals:Patient satisfaction increases when their healthcare team initiates referrals relieving the patient of this responsibility.
- Continuity of care:Patient satisfaction increases when they receive continuing care from the same healthcare provider(s).
- Dignity:As expected, patients who are treated with respect and who are invited to partner in their healthcare decisions report greater satisfaction.
- An estimated one-third of adverse events are attributed to human error and system errors
- Research conducted during the 10 year period of 1995-2005 has demonstrated that ineffective team communication is the root cause for nearly 66 percent of all medical errors during that period.
- This means that when health care team members do not communicate effectively, patient care often suffers.
- Further, medical error vulnerability is increased when healthcare team members are under stress, are in high-task situations, and when they are not communicating clearly or effectively
Why is team satisfaction important?
- Communication among healthcare team members influences the quality of working relationships, job satisfaction and profound impacts patient safety.
- When communication about tasks and responsibilities are done well, research evidence has shown significant reduction in nurse turnoverand improved job satisfaction because it facilitates a culture of mutual support
- Larson and Yaofound a direct relationship between clinicians’ level of satisfaction and their ability to build rapport and express care and warmth with patients.
What are the elements that contribute to healthcare team satisfaction: Feeling supported, e.g., administratively and inter-personally, respected, valued, understood, listened to, having a clear understanding of role, work equity and fair compensation.
- According to Huntington and Kuhn, the “root cause” of malpractice claims is a breakdown in communication between physician and patient.
- Previous researchthat examined plaintiff depositions found that 71% of the malpractice claims were initiated as a result of a physician-patient relationship problem. Closer inspection found that most litigious patients perceived their physician as uncaring . The same researchers found that one out of four plaintiffs in malpractice cases reported poor delivery of medical information, with 13% citing poor listening on the part of the physician
Research evidence indicates that there are strong positive relationships between a healthcare team member’s communication skills and a patient’s capacity to follow through with medical recommendations, self-manage a chronic medical condition, and adopt preventive health behaviors. Studies show that the clinician’s ability to explain, listen and empathize can have a profound effect on biological and functional health outcomes as well as patient satisfaction and experience of care. Further, communication among healthcare team members influences the quality of working relationships, job satisfaction and has a profound impact on patient safety.
Clinicians and other members of the healthcare team conduct thousands of patient interactions during their career. The call to action from the Institute of Medicine (IOM) Report on Health Professions and Training underscores the importance of communication training for clinicians and members of the healthcare team. Similar to other healthcare procedures, communication skills can be learned and improved upon. Improvement in communication skills requires commitment and practice.
Given the wealth of evidence linking ineffective clinician-patient communication with increased malpractice risk, nonadherence, patient and clinician dissatisfaction, and poor patient health outcomes, the necessity of addressing communication skill deficits is of the utmost importance.